A little guidance for each book, and where it might take you next.
01. One of Us Is Lying
Karen M. McManus
Begin with five students in detention, a death, and four stories that do not quite fit.
Next: One of Us Is Next
02. One of Us Is Next
Karen M. McManus
Revisit Bayview through another mystery and watch how secrets travel through a school community.
Next: One of Us Is Back
03. One of Us Is Back
Karen M. McManus
Complete the selected Bayview trilogy by considering how earlier suspicions follow people into another investigation.
Next: The Inheritance Games
04. The Inheritance Games
Jennifer Lynn Barnes
Try a mansion full of puzzles and a girl who has inherited money for reasons she cannot explain.
Next: The Hawthorne Legacy
05. The Hawthorne Legacy
Jennifer Lynn Barnes
Look deeper into the Hawthorne family's puzzles, where an inheritance creates questions as quickly as it answers them.
Next: The Final Gambit
06. The Final Gambit
Jennifer Lynn Barnes
Finish Avery's initial Inheritance Games trilogy with the difference between winning a puzzle and understanding its players in mind.
Next: The Naturals
07. The Naturals
Jennifer Lynn Barnes
Meet teenagers trained to help solve crimes because of their unusual skills.
Next: Killer Instinct
08. Killer Instinct
Jennifer Lynn Barnes
Stay with the Naturals' young investigators and watch how their personal histories affect the way they read a crime.
Next: All In
09. All In
Jennifer Lynn Barnes
Follow another Naturals case, comparing the team's unusual skills with the risks of believing they can predict people.
Next: Bad Blood
10. Bad Blood
Jennifer Lynn Barnes
Complete the main Naturals quartet with the boundary between an investigator's own story and a case becoming harder to hold.
Next: A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
11. A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
Holly Jackson
Follow a student who does not accept the official answer to a local murder.
Next: Good Girl, Bad Blood
12. Good Girl, Bad Blood
Holly Jackson
Return to Pip's investigations and consider what changes when asking questions is no longer just a school project.
Next: As Good as Dead
13. As Good as Dead
Holly Jackson
Finish Pip's trilogy with the personal cost of pursuing answers beside the satisfaction of solving a case.
Next: Sadie
14. Sadie
Courtney Summers
Take a darker road trip, following a girl searching for the man who killed her sister.
Next: Monday's Not Coming
15. Monday's Not Coming
Tiffany D. Jackson
End with a missing best friend and the troubling question of why so few people seem to care.